{ "schema_version": 1, "collection": "candidates", "generated_at": "2026-11-02", "source": "https://gxplex.com", "notice": "Reports the published status of regulatory documents. No advice or interpretation.", "source_terms": "This site compiles publicly available regulatory information. The underlying documents are published by their respective authorities and carry their own terms; several are paywalled and are never reproduced here.", "rights": { "statement": "Carried in `source_terms` on this envelope. It is the whole of what this record states on the subject.", "per_row_field": "licence_class", "per_row_field_served_at": "https://gxplex.com/api/v1/instruments.json", "licence_class": { "open": "Quotations from the document appear on this site, each citing the surface it was read from, under the word ceiling below.", "restricted": "No text from the document appears on this site. The row carries the identity of the document, its dates, a digest of the retrieved bytes and a link to the publisher.", "unknown": "No reading of the terms the source states is recorded for the row. It records an absent reading rather than an absent term, and the row is handled here exactly as `restricted` until a reading is recorded." }, "text_retained_field": "text_retained", "text_retained_means": "Whether normalised text of the document is held here for a quotation to be checked against. Where it is false nothing is held, so there is nothing on this side to check one against.", "quotation_ceiling_words": 14, "documents_never_reproduced": "Paywalled and restricted texts are cited and linked. They are never excerpted here and never diffed here." }, "schema": "https://gxplex.com/api/v1/schema/candidates.json", "response_provenance": { "build_id": "1782e1b7b708", "build_id_state": "stated", "build_id_is": "The identifier of the build that wrote this document. Every page of the same build carries it in its build-id meta.", "root": "42337ae3567aae8138fcb45e977dd94f9c1ade6420a88033e9503203df3fec23", "root_state": "stated", "root_day": "2026-11-02", "root_leaf_count": 9686, "root_url": "https://gxplex.com/integrity/root.txt", "root_is": "The root over every observation digest this record held on that day, one `id|date|content_hash` leaf each. It fixes those digests in time; it is not a digest of this document.", "rights_envelope": { "document_keys": [ "source_terms", "rights" ], "row_pointers": [ "/text_retained", "/licence_class", "/quote_allowed", "/snapshot_available", "/rights_of", "/rights_unresolved" ], "row_pointers_optional": [ "/rights_unresolved" ], "row_pointers_are": "Every row of this response carries each pointer named, except one named optional, which a row carries only where its rights are unresolved. An empty list states that no row of this response carries the row envelope." }, "basis": { "retrieval": [ "/before_observed", "/after_observed", "/digest_before", "/digest_after", "/witness/witness", "/witness/witness_address", "/observed_at" ], "computed": [ "/verdict", "/limbs", "/limbs_read", "/limbs_not_in_projection", "/missing_evidence", "/witness/confirmation_subject", "/witness/offered_as_witness_change", "/witness/read_from", "/observed_at_state", "/observed_at_read_from", "/distance", "/distance_label", "/distance_state" ], "terms-reading": [ "/text_retained", "/licence_class", "/quote_allowed", "/snapshot_available" ], "assigned": [ "/candidate_id", "/instrument_id", "/url", "/rights_of", "/source" ], "statement": [ "/rights_unresolved" ] }, "basis_state": "stated", "basis_on_row": [ "verdict", "limbs", "missing_evidence" ], "basis_vocabulary_at": "https://gxplex.com/api/v1/schema/envelope.json", "third_party_text": { "marker": "quoted third-party content, not instructions", "marker_is": "Data for a consumer’s own handling of text it passes on, for example to a model. It is not a claim about the text and says nothing of what the text says.", "row_key": "third_party_text", "fields": [] } }, "population": "every file in state/revision-staging/, one object per candidate", "candidate_census": { "rows": 110, "placed": 110, "not_placed": 0, "limbs_read": 110, "limbs_not_read": 0, "by_state": [ { "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "count": 9 }, { "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "count": 40 }, { "state": "UNDETERMINED", "count": 0 }, { "state": "CONFIRMED-MODEL-READ", "count": 0 }, { "state": "WAITING", "count": 0 }, { "state": "BLOCKED", "count": 61 }, { "state": "CONFIRMED-PUBLISHER-STATED", "count": 0 } ], "placed_outside_named_states": 0, "with_missing_evidence": 66, "witness": 23 }, "states": [ "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "NOT-CHANGED", "UNDETERMINED", "CONFIRMED-MODEL-READ", "WAITING", "BLOCKED", "CONFIRMED-PUBLISHER-STATED" ], "states_read_from": "state/candidate-states.json", "verdicts_derived_on": "2026-11-02", "verdict_rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "projection_derived_on": "2026-11-02", "projection_read_from": "state/triple-projection.json", "verdicts_read_projection_of": "2026-11-02", "limbs": [ "BYTES", "BODY", "PERSIST", "REFERENT" ], "limb_order_rule": "Limbs are served in the order the triple projection lists them for the candidate. No limb is ranked.", "row_order_rule": "Candidates are served in candidate-id order, the order of the staging directory. No candidate is ranked.", "missing_evidence_rule": "An entry is read from a field whose writer states an absence of evidence: the verdict's `needs`; the limb flags `waiting`, `blocked`, `below_floor`, `readings_needed`, `class_lacks`, `unanchored`, `incomplete`, `missing_side` and `unaudited`; and the limb values `extractor_verdict` UNDERIVABLE, `span_verdict` UNDETERMINED and `referent_verdict` UNAUDITED. Every other limb flag is carried in that limb's `flags` and is not read for this list. An empty list means these fields were read and named no lack; null means the candidate has no row to read them from.", "not_carried": [ { "field": "value, quote", "why": "A recorded model read is carried by its receipt id and its resolution. The output text it recorded is not served in this document." }, { "field": "statements[].stated_token", "why": "A publisher-stated confirmation is served with each note's source, field, surface, day and the rule the day was read by. The token the day was read from is not served: for a GOV.UK note it is an instant with a clock time. No note's text is held in the verdict file." } ], "candidate_pages_read": "Each item's `url` is its candidate page, which renders the verdict and confirm gate read from `state/rescreen.json`, not this document's verdict file. The two can name different states for one candidate.", "rights_fields": { "fields": [ "text_retained", "licence_class", "quote_allowed", "snapshot_available" ], "rows": 110, "rows_with_a_reading": 110, "rows_without_a_reading": 0, "rows_naming_an_unheld_id": 0, "rows_naming_no_entry": 0, "licence_class": { "open": 107, "restricted": 3, "unknown": 0 }, "quote_allowed_true": 107, "quote_allowed_false": 3, "text_retained_true": 110, "snapshot_available_true": 110, "retained_here_but_not_quoted_here": 3, "snapshot_without_prose": 0, "nulls_mean_unheld_id": "This id resolves to no tracked entry, so no terms reading, no retention measurement and no snapshot measurement exists for it. Four nulls record the absence of a reading, never a reading that came back negative.", "nulls_mean_no_entry": "This object names no tracked entry, so no terms reading was looked for. Four nulls record that no lookup applies here, which is a different fact from a lookup that found nothing." }, "provenance_fields": { "fields": [ "source", "observed_at", "distance" ], "rows": 110, "source_tracked": 110, "source_not_tracked": 0, "source_no_subject": 0, "observed_at_recorded": 110, "observed_at_not_carried": 0, "observed_at_not_an_observation": 0, "observed_at_fields_read": [ "after_observed" ], "distance_by_state": { "not-a-signal": 110 }, "distance_by_value": [ { "key": "0 primary", "count": 0 }, { "key": "1 official notice", "count": 0 }, { "key": "2 official related record", "count": 0 }, { "key": "3 third-party", "count": 0 } ] }, "count": 110, "items": [ { "candidate_id": "astm-e2363-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "astm-e2363", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/astm-e2363-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "a153d64e3bb5225b0c1d204cb68792f62cf87daaed7b3ff2ce9fbbdea4a9fe5e", "digest_after": "38fca073725a8580e33f943a252f9793b151822380f626e9ccddf52c47713913", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-09", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "restricted", "quote_allowed": false, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "astm-e2363", "source": { "id": "astm-e2363", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/astm-e2363" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "astm-e2363-2026-10-28", "instrument_id": "astm-e2363", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/astm-e2363-2026-10-28/", "before_observed": "2026-10-27", "after_observed": "2026-10-28", "digest_before": "38fca073725a8580e33f943a252f9793b151822380f626e9ccddf52c47713913", "digest_after": "0db7930b76cd2e7dc3890ecf4abac3aa6e55f514f05053eb0707f94e3d3c9fe5", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-10-29", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "restricted", "quote_allowed": false, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "astm-e2363", "source": { "id": "astm-e2363", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/astm-e2363" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "astm-e2500-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "astm-e2500", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/astm-e2500-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "492749881d21e9c5cb1cd9411a865de30e7cbe9e6c885254e3fd6c6602afea66", "digest_after": "f8a0b4003e887ef95ac41917e284c79600966a67d253725035c2851a6d560010", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-09", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "restricted", "quote_allowed": false, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "astm-e2500", "source": { "id": "astm-e2500", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/astm-e2500" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-07-29", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-07-29/", "before_observed": "2026-07-28", "after_observed": "2026-07-29", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "BYTES", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "equal-digests", "detail": "the two digests are equal: the retained text does not differ" }, { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 98 of 115 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (58 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the two digests are equal: the retained text does not differ", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": true, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 98 of 115 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (58 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-07-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-13", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-13/", "before_observed": "2026-08-12", "after_observed": "2026-08-13", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-22 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-22 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-13", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-14", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-14/", "before_observed": "2026-08-13", "after_observed": "2026-08-14", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-23 and 24 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-23 and 24 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-15", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-15/", "before_observed": "2026-08-14", "after_observed": "2026-08-15", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-22 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-22 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-15", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-22", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-22/", "before_observed": "2026-08-21", "after_observed": "2026-08-22", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-26 and 22 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-26 and 22 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-22", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-23", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-23/", "before_observed": "2026-08-22", "after_observed": "2026-08-23", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-25 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-25 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-23", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-25", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-08-25/", "before_observed": "2026-08-24", "after_observed": "2026-08-25", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-04 and 10 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-04 and 10 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-25", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-03", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-03/", "before_observed": "2026-09-02", "after_observed": "2026-09-03", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-04 and 10 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-04 and 10 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-03", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-04", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-04/", "before_observed": "2026-09-03", "after_observed": "2026-09-04", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "BYTES", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "equal-digests", "detail": "the two digests are equal: the retained text does not differ" }, { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 10 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the two digests are equal: the retained text does not differ", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": true, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 10 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-04", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-05", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-05/", "before_observed": "2026-09-04", "after_observed": "2026-09-05", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "2 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (58 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 2, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (58 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (58 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 2, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-05", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-11", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-11/", "before_observed": "2026-09-10", "after_observed": "2026-09-11", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "1 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 1, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 1, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-11", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-12", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-12/", "before_observed": "2026-09-11", "after_observed": "2026-09-12", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "2 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 2, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (51 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 2, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-12", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-14", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-14/", "before_observed": "2026-09-13", "after_observed": "2026-09-14", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 50 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]" }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "all 50 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": true, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": [ "4472b78002d0" ], "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "blocked", "value": true, "why": "all 50 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-16", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-16/", "before_observed": "2026-09-15", "after_observed": "2026-09-16", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-26 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-09-26 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-16", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-26", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-26/", "before_observed": "2026-09-25", "after_observed": "2026-09-26", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 30 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 30 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-26", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-27", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-27/", "before_observed": "2026-09-26", "after_observed": "2026-09-27", "digest_before": "863f5ab39635ca89bc0ae1c49ddd75740616ef2970e9651d56e69fca0634ce01", "digest_after": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 29 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 29 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-27", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-29", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-29/", "before_observed": "2026-09-28", "after_observed": "2026-09-29", "digest_before": "eb42a10342ad597462395f790b666b2c47c8b8ff10b10201ca66c02dba3195e9", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "unlike-readings", "detail": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'canonical-redirect' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "unlike-readings", "detail": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'canonical-redirect' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text" }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 5 of 27 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'canonical-redirect' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": true, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 5 of 27 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-30", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-09-30/", "before_observed": "2026-09-29", "after_observed": "2026-09-30", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-02 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-02 and 4 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-30", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-02", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-02/", "before_observed": "2026-10-01", "after_observed": "2026-10-02", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-05 and 18 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-05 and 18 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-03", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-03/", "before_observed": "2026-10-02", "after_observed": "2026-10-03", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-10 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-10 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-03", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-04", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-04/", "before_observed": "2026-10-03", "after_observed": "2026-10-04", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-11 and 13 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-11 and 13 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-04", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-05", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-05/", "before_observed": "2026-10-04", "after_observed": "2026-10-05", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-10 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-10 and 2 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-05", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-10", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-10/", "before_observed": "2026-10-09", "after_observed": "2026-10-10", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-19 and 6 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-19 and 6 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-11", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-11/", "before_observed": "2026-10-10", "after_observed": "2026-10-11", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-17 and 1 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-17 and 1 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-11", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-17", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-17/", "before_observed": "2026-10-16", "after_observed": "2026-10-17", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-19 and 6 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-19 and 6 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-17", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-19", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-19/", "before_observed": "2026-10-18", "after_observed": "2026-10-19", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "6 of 6 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-10-20", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-19", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-30", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-30/", "before_observed": "2026-10-29", "after_observed": "2026-10-30", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-11-02 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-11-02 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-30", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-31", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-10-31/", "before_observed": "2026-10-30", "after_observed": "2026-10-31", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "1 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 1, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 1, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-31", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-11-01", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-11-01/", "before_observed": "2026-10-31", "after_observed": "2026-11-01", "digest_before": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "digest_after": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "2 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 2, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 2, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-11-01", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "ema-ai-reflection-2026-11-02", "instrument_id": "ema-ai-reflection", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/ema-ai-reflection-2026-11-02/", "before_observed": "2026-11-01", "after_observed": "2026-11-02", "digest_before": "3e7ec4b884cee24e2d58f3e6388ff66c48e24c2d3fe70ae7c6f70e706e325924", "digest_after": "36c41987de4a749de37df19cebd65f76c83146c469883b0dc7c60a5207de3e68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "3 later observation(s) of ema-ai-reflection under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "no observation of this row exists after the candidate's day, so persistence has not been measured — it is waiting, not failed", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": 3, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "no observation of this row exists after the candidate's day, so persistence has not been measured — it is waiting, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 3, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.ema.europa.eu/en/scientific-guidelines/use-artificial-intelligence-ai-medicinal-product-lifecycle", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "ema-ai-reflection", "source": { "id": "ema-ai-reflection", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/ema-ai-reflection" }, "observed_at": "2026-11-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-20", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-20/", "before_observed": "2026-08-19", "after_observed": "2026-08-20", "digest_before": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "digest_after": "088a7a37c55d7a9852343358802ebdfdf79d23a655f26e6fa4b056cce2ca1e37", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-28 and 20 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": true, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-28 and 20 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-20", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-21", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-21/", "before_observed": "2026-08-20", "after_observed": "2026-08-21", "digest_before": "088a7a37c55d7a9852343358802ebdfdf79d23a655f26e6fa4b056cce2ca1e37", "digest_after": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-27 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": true, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-08-27 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-21", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-27", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-27/", "before_observed": "2026-08-26", "after_observed": "2026-08-27", "digest_before": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "digest_after": "088a7a37c55d7a9852343358802ebdfdf79d23a655f26e6fa4b056cce2ca1e37", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 22 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the after side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": true, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 22 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-27", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-28", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-08-28/", "before_observed": "2026-08-27", "after_observed": "2026-08-28", "digest_before": "088a7a37c55d7a9852343358802ebdfdf79d23a655f26e6fa4b056cce2ca1e37", "digest_after": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "not-the-artifact", "detail": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 20 of 21 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (112 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the before side is classed 'non-document' — it answered at https://www.fda.gov/about-fda/page-not-found, which is not the artifact this row names", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": true, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 20 of 21 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (112 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-09-01", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-09-01/", "before_observed": "2026-08-31", "after_observed": "2026-09-01", "digest_before": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "digest_after": "630bd27c7b423644b81cb207f479891c87987496d6a8d3a004def7b0f6473ea4", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "reverted", "cause": null, "detail": "none of the 15 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 15 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 15 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-01", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-ai-guidance-2026-09-02", "instrument_id": "fda-ai-guidance", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-ai-guidance-2026-09-02/", "before_observed": "2026-09-01", "after_observed": "2026-09-02", "digest_before": "630bd27c7b423644b81cb207f479891c87987496d6a8d3a004def7b0f6473ea4", "digest_after": "61d4603ff66e3a307239a38601161bb52bd5a679ef51125c220efd26572e187d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "13 of 13 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-03", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-ai-guidance", "source": { "id": "fda-ai-guidance", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-ai-guidance" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-aiml-device-list-2026-09-23", "instrument_id": "fda-aiml-device-list", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-aiml-device-list-2026-09-23/", "before_observed": "2026-09-22", "after_observed": "2026-09-23", "digest_before": "a55b6f369034fcbb5f434b9ae550078c7f41c891770da8448d6e952b4385b7fb", "digest_after": "f0d90446093eef1bcb78e5f90340eba2eb9b5c4d0354c52f533994383ac4a1bd", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own source_kind is 'register', which is not a document: movement here is movement of a listing", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own source_kind is 'register', which is not a document: movement here is movement of a listing", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own source_kind is 'register', which is not a document: movement here is movement of a listing", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own source_kind is 'register', which is not a document: movement here is movement of a listing", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-aiml-device-list", "source": { "id": "fda-aiml-device-list", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-aiml-device-list" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-23", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "fda-gmlp-2026-09-23", "instrument_id": "fda-gmlp", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/fda-gmlp-2026-09-23/", "before_observed": "2026-09-22", "after_observed": "2026-09-23", "digest_before": "ef0dfb4023b7025fce6599e8601cb3c2f246b887e3898de771dd574ba4ffb34b", "digest_after": "2091aa6e2741cc0f37d84f7dba4e0be719e8800e7ebb5f82975b8af6cb3ca8be", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "unlike-readings", "detail": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'document' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "unlike-readings", "detail": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'document' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text" }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the two sides are not the same kind of reading — 'document' before and 'witness' after, so a difference between them is this record's aim moving, not the publisher's text", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": true, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "34 of 34 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-24", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/artificial-intelligence-enabled-medical-devices/good-machine-learning-practice-medical-device-development-guiding-principles", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "fda-gmlp", "source": { "id": "fda-gmlp", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/fda-gmlp" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-23", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "health-canada-ml-2026-08-25", "instrument_id": "health-canada-ml", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/health-canada-ml-2026-08-25/", "before_observed": "2026-08-24", "after_observed": "2026-08-25", "digest_before": "2988351a1019fc29398adca9e3ad509c8f1360c88dc65c0d99de973da8354884", "digest_after": "f34e637e74cb0d5a4b351061a3fea213396656d9e2cde662314cc99b5d0408e6", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row declares source_kind: document and its reading carries 77 dated list entries — the address it hashes serves a list, and the document it names is not that list", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row declares source_kind: document and its reading carries 77 dated list entries — the address it hashes serves a list, and the document it names is not that list" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "25 of 25 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-08-26", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row declares source_kind: document and its reading carries 77 dated list entries — the address it hashes serves a list, and the document it names is not that list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "health-canada-ml", "source": { "id": "health-canada-ml", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/health-canada-ml" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-25", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "110d6c8e7c56695c1d9d6e142f6bbef244d128fd9a9a43aac8178a00bfdb04d2", "digest_after": "d4b6bb0450a88d7f3c23a74b60b24949f0dd71b7d974a7fb09f142095c33384b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 5 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 5 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-09", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-09/", "before_observed": "2026-09-08", "after_observed": "2026-09-09", "digest_before": "d4b6bb0450a88d7f3c23a74b60b24949f0dd71b7d974a7fb09f142095c33384b", "digest_after": "0d4b2abb3a4fdc70b67096c0eafb5ed0e5dfa726bbdbfcb5797a712757b30aac", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 4 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 4 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-09", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-10", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-10/", "before_observed": "2026-09-09", "after_observed": "2026-09-10", "digest_before": "0d4b2abb3a4fdc70b67096c0eafb5ed0e5dfa726bbdbfcb5797a712757b30aac", "digest_after": "8fc70fdfe3a5f042bff55fa7c11a67c77b2f13f76b6f8eec3000728700c089c2", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 3 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 3 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-11", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-11/", "before_observed": "2026-09-10", "after_observed": "2026-09-11", "digest_before": "8fc70fdfe3a5f042bff55fa7c11a67c77b2f13f76b6f8eec3000728700c089c2", "digest_after": "95ff73c7efa26058465bf11ac1d968a97a02f9c9915ae31e4fa989a914853f7a", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "1 later observation(s) of mhra-ai under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 1, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 1, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-11", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-12", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-12/", "before_observed": "2026-09-11", "after_observed": "2026-09-12", "digest_before": "95ff73c7efa26058465bf11ac1d968a97a02f9c9915ae31e4fa989a914853f7a", "digest_after": "21fde7c052b400702464b718b815337971e5757ea8ed070bfbd569dafc49b35d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "2 later observation(s) of mhra-ai under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 2, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 2, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-12", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-13", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-13/", "before_observed": "2026-09-12", "after_observed": "2026-09-13", "digest_before": "21fde7c052b400702464b718b815337971e5757ea8ed070bfbd569dafc49b35d", "digest_after": "d722379e4120a9c4c8f76d1bb52c7a08e79bd5af11d92ac6ba69c1b31cde2403", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]" }, { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": true, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": [ "4472b78002d0" ], "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "blocked", "value": true, "why": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-13", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-14", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-14/", "before_observed": "2026-09-13", "after_observed": "2026-09-14", "digest_before": "d722379e4120a9c4c8f76d1bb52c7a08e79bd5af11d92ac6ba69c1b31cde2403", "digest_after": "f61cf3af50631aaf06a7a9d0cb561121fc90f598cf503b9a402dc4393c643fec", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": true, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": [ "4472b78002d0" ], "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "blocked", "value": true, "why": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-09-15", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-09-15/", "before_observed": "2026-09-14", "after_observed": "2026-09-15", "digest_before": "f61cf3af50631aaf06a7a9d0cb561121fc90f598cf503b9a402dc4393c643fec", "digest_after": "110d6c8e7c56695c1d9d6e142f6bbef244d128fd9a9a43aac8178a00bfdb04d2", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 22 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on one side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 22 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on one side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-15", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-10-06", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-10-06/", "before_observed": "2026-10-05", "after_observed": "2026-10-06", "digest_before": "110d6c8e7c56695c1d9d6e142f6bbef244d128fd9a9a43aac8178a00bfdb04d2", "digest_after": "adda145eadf9734bb93a6bef157c129c86f7b3b7985cfb87199adf511273b28c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "oscillation", "cause": null, "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-06", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-10-09", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-10-09/", "before_observed": "2026-10-08", "after_observed": "2026-10-09", "digest_before": "adda145eadf9734bb93a6bef157c129c86f7b3b7985cfb87199adf511273b28c", "digest_after": "110d6c8e7c56695c1d9d6e142f6bbef244d128fd9a9a43aac8178a00bfdb04d2", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "reverted", "cause": null, "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-09", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-ai-2026-10-10", "instrument_id": "mhra-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-ai-2026-10-10/", "before_observed": "2026-10-09", "after_observed": "2026-10-10", "digest_before": "110d6c8e7c56695c1d9d6e142f6bbef244d128fd9a9a43aac8178a00bfdb04d2", "digest_after": "adda145eadf9734bb93a6bef157c129c86f7b3b7985cfb87199adf511273b28c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "16 of 16 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-10-11", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-ai", "source": { "id": "mhra-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "c330704e7caaecdaf177bab279b28adc623ce786d6478774e9715b1f73c7229c", "digest_after": "13971812bd5771b549c455d2e6e6b391f1326e76a2963d9cc1420c4af6e4a759", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 5 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 5 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-09", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-09/", "before_observed": "2026-09-08", "after_observed": "2026-09-09", "digest_before": "13971812bd5771b549c455d2e6e6b391f1326e76a2963d9cc1420c4af6e4a759", "digest_after": "6903993ae01bf24f5fa45271e5d67fdd47f434bd5385e308bc543221cfdedf2e", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 4 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 4 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-09", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-10", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-10/", "before_observed": "2026-09-09", "after_observed": "2026-09-10", "digest_before": "6903993ae01bf24f5fa45271e5d67fdd47f434bd5385e308bc543221cfdedf2e", "digest_after": "aadc8bf624987bca7860dca3b96436b8dff19961bcab5e7bba9ff930917994e1", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 3 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 3 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-11", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-11/", "before_observed": "2026-09-10", "after_observed": "2026-09-11", "digest_before": "aadc8bf624987bca7860dca3b96436b8dff19961bcab5e7bba9ff930917994e1", "digest_after": "9a0948cb5e5b50e0737685231546b3c985e79491f79d58e654c0dd985f1ee7d3", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "1 later observation(s) of mhra-data-integrity under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 1, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 1, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-11", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-12", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-12/", "before_observed": "2026-09-11", "after_observed": "2026-09-12", "digest_before": "9a0948cb5e5b50e0737685231546b3c985e79491f79d58e654c0dd985f1ee7d3", "digest_after": "5f23d775ccaa1f2ee6833192dfd82e0d55e736b50783dabd96407c52a44850de", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "2 later observation(s) of mhra-data-integrity under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 2, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 1 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed (52 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 2, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-12", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-13", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-13/", "before_observed": "2026-09-12", "after_observed": "2026-09-13", "digest_before": "5f23d775ccaa1f2ee6833192dfd82e0d55e736b50783dabd96407c52a44850de", "digest_after": "f4ddeaad589b602d637088464edb2fb780becb2ae6ab22952e92a48c2b0304d2", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]" }, { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": true, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": [ "4472b78002d0" ], "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "blocked", "value": true, "why": "all 52 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-13", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-14", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-14/", "before_observed": "2026-09-13", "after_observed": "2026-09-14", "digest_before": "f4ddeaad589b602d637088464edb2fb780becb2ae6ab22952e92a48c2b0304d2", "digest_after": "fe6722320c02845dd9b22e287d5bbac57ef1a30d65dfe5c3d0acf2e609eed772", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-after", "detail": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting [commits: 4472b78002d0]" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-13 and 2026-09-14", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": true, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": [ "4472b78002d0" ], "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "blocked", "value": true, "why": "all 51 later observation(s) sit past a change to the extractor (4472b78002d0), so the window under this candidate's own extractor is closed and no later reading can reopen it: blocked, not waiting", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-15", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-15/", "before_observed": "2026-09-14", "after_observed": "2026-09-15", "digest_before": "fe6722320c02845dd9b22e287d5bbac57ef1a30d65dfe5c3d0acf2e609eed772", "digest_after": "c330704e7caaecdaf177bab279b28adc623ce786d6478774e9715b1f73c7229c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 1 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-14 and 2026-09-15", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on one side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on one side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-15", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-17", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-09-17/", "before_observed": "2026-09-16", "after_observed": "2026-09-17", "digest_before": "c330704e7caaecdaf177bab279b28adc623ce786d6478774e9715b1f73c7229c", "digest_after": "ced856cd0b5a1c8e0e048231afd2fa76442c0ca13dabba883498be01087f588b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "unstable", "cause": null, "detail": "the new digest holds on only 20 of 40 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 20 of 40 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 20 of 40 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (8 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-17", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-06", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-06/", "before_observed": "2026-10-05", "after_observed": "2026-10-06", "digest_before": "ced856cd0b5a1c8e0e048231afd2fa76442c0ca13dabba883498be01087f588b", "digest_after": "c59c1f4d83779d0778c985a36975d15cc912ad37fe5edb15304cb8e31f73786c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "oscillation", "cause": null, "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "oscillation", "detail": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest recurs but the PRIOR digest also returns after it, on 2026-10-09 and 0 other day(s): the page is served in two states rather than having moved between them", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": true, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-06", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-09", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-09/", "before_observed": "2026-10-08", "after_observed": "2026-10-09", "digest_before": "c59c1f4d83779d0778c985a36975d15cc912ad37fe5edb15304cb8e31f73786c", "digest_after": "ced856cd0b5a1c8e0e048231afd2fa76442c0ca13dabba883498be01087f588b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "reverted", "cause": null, "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-09", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-10", "instrument_id": "mhra-data-integrity", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/mhra-data-integrity-2026-10-10/", "before_observed": "2026-10-09", "after_observed": "2026-10-10", "digest_before": "ced856cd0b5a1c8e0e048231afd2fa76442c0ca13dabba883498be01087f588b", "digest_after": "c59c1f4d83779d0778c985a36975d15cc912ad37fe5edb15304cb8e31f73786c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "16 of 16 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-10-11", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "mhra-data-integrity", "source": { "id": "mhra-data-integrity", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/mhra-data-integrity" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nist-ai-rmf-2026-08-14", "instrument_id": "nist-ai-rmf", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nist-ai-rmf-2026-08-14/", "before_observed": "2026-08-13", "after_observed": "2026-08-14", "digest_before": "8afebcc0941aa5cca964f2dd577132fc65a33919f220c0792e2799015cf95826", "digest_after": "c240f2675bd38b9021b124e33378811068973960addb1ba8925fd8bbc9e8cbb5", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "43 of 43 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-08-15", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework", "offered_as_witness_change": true, "confirmation_subject": "witness", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nist-ai-rmf", "source": { "id": "nist-ai-rmf", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nist-ai-rmf" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nist-csf-2026-10-31", "instrument_id": "nist-csf", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nist-csf-2026-10-31/", "before_observed": "2026-10-30", "after_observed": "2026-10-31", "digest_before": "58453f40334e9fdfe7120011e7e72aabc0f294bcdc357ea1d8976ad64419357d", "digest_after": "9ab6869e7569d8793cd3b630226b4e8d67a78d9f2bbc0d24fac94c95f6a8852b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "REFERENT", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "referent-mismatch", "detail": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "WAITING", "class": "later-readings", "detail": "1 later observation(s) of nist-csf under the extractor current on the candidate's day" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "flags": { "waiting": true, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": true, "readings_needed": 1, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "AUDITED-MISMATCH: the row hashes an address it does not declare", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": true, "referent_verdict": "AUDITED-MISMATCH", "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "waiting", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "below_floor", "value": true, "why": "only 2 later observation(s) were taken under the same extractor, and 3 is the fewest that can tell holding from alternating: persistence is unmeasured, not failed", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "field": "readings_needed", "value": 1, "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": true, "witness_address": "https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/cswp/29/the-nist-cybersecurity-framework-csf-20/final", "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nist-csf", "source": { "id": "nist-csf", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nist-csf" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-31", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nist-sp-800-82-2026-09-22", "instrument_id": "nist-sp-800-82", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nist-sp-800-82-2026-09-22/", "before_observed": "2026-09-21", "after_observed": "2026-09-22", "digest_before": "eae63eec79c3f449dbf735d5a79ce590bf622927ceef117e29b5c602576f3454", "digest_after": "3e7e350389ef6cb543f0204bb056954626a79871ba6d0999dba293d4b8db9a4b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "35 of 35 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-23", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nist-sp-800-82", "source": { "id": "nist-sp-800-82", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nist-sp-800-82" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-22", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-08-21", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-08-21/", "before_observed": "2026-08-20", "after_observed": "2026-08-21", "digest_before": "b842380c2707538f1080d5bf7b969f15c2c5147f91a1e05f4c19e97d8dc8aef2", "digest_after": "64cfa49f68039cb0b2753fa2f9f56d69e482960222eb267155b6e8b8e5c9a410", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-21", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-09-23", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-09-23/", "before_observed": "2026-09-22", "after_observed": "2026-09-23", "digest_before": "0137915a568ecf0116ef1e1e9e48c26bed4bbb68bb9227d501af2592cf68f065", "digest_after": "73f428021dbd6ee563fc0444fa1b66da28d0c635178e4b680a80e820cd500b6b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-23", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-10-01", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-10-01/", "before_observed": "2026-09-30", "after_observed": "2026-10-01", "digest_before": "73f428021dbd6ee563fc0444fa1b66da28d0c635178e4b680a80e820cd500b6b", "digest_after": "9f00d9ed53c384af63f328a7a1ff595f580b09acf29fc19ddc5d254cd131cc26", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-01", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-10-23", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-10-23/", "before_observed": "2026-10-22", "after_observed": "2026-10-23", "digest_before": "9f00d9ed53c384af63f328a7a1ff595f580b09acf29fc19ddc5d254cd131cc26", "digest_after": "1fee901ddeb0ef6798d9703ec7953342d2e5528d2ceb6bebf20ddde8430b270d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-23", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-10-27", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-10-27/", "before_observed": "2026-10-26", "after_observed": "2026-10-27", "digest_before": "1fee901ddeb0ef6798d9703ec7953342d2e5528d2ceb6bebf20ddde8430b270d", "digest_after": "7942361389fb3a55edcd06297d4b46f42ab8c5ed0cdd2b52348c288addf6c5e1", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-27", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-10-28", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-10-28/", "before_observed": "2026-10-27", "after_observed": "2026-10-28", "digest_before": "7942361389fb3a55edcd06297d4b46f42ab8c5ed0cdd2b52348c288addf6c5e1", "digest_after": "dfff799b5b6ea2211431c9acd84693d065419546745654419b92eb32cd0f8eb0", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-10-30", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-10-30/", "before_observed": "2026-10-29", "after_observed": "2026-10-30", "digest_before": "dfff799b5b6ea2211431c9acd84693d065419546745654419b92eb32cd0f8eb0", "digest_after": "5a6df3d8707e0b7f764c8644286db0bc58e6b314f5a1137a71430e7c04d6c6b1", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-30", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "nmpa-ai-2026-11-02", "instrument_id": "nmpa-ai", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/nmpa-ai-2026-11-02/", "before_observed": "2026-11-01", "after_observed": "2026-11-02", "digest_before": "5a6df3d8707e0b7f764c8644286db0bc58e6b314f5a1137a71430e7c04d6c6b1", "digest_after": "4a80b86d52c08b01667e390a85b14e724944f4e78ba9ca6ff657eb130cde5c8e", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "nmpa-ai", "source": { "id": "nmpa-ai", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/nmpa-ai" }, "observed_at": "2026-11-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "pics-pi-011-2026-09-24", "instrument_id": "pics-pi-011", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/pics-pi-011-2026-09-24/", "before_observed": "2026-09-23", "after_observed": "2026-09-24", "digest_before": "778926fbdd90c223289a4685e5182494dcef06eeee0099acaaf629efd14eaaaa", "digest_after": "cf40bfac8ed76b1af8e5990eb74284e7109844bccb2c699c96f2f7da6787b7b2", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "pics-pi-011", "source": { "id": "pics-pi-011", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/pics-pi-011" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-24", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "pics-pi-011-2026-10-29", "instrument_id": "pics-pi-011", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/pics-pi-011-2026-10-29/", "before_observed": "2026-10-28", "after_observed": "2026-10-29", "digest_before": "cf40bfac8ed76b1af8e5990eb74284e7109844bccb2c699c96f2f7da6787b7b2", "digest_after": "da4137a554be5c59ceae41e1e987a369836d0898cda069113e02f2bec35e1402", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "row-declares-listing", "detail": "the row declares itself: the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the row's own frozen_reason is listing_only: it tracks a listing, and a listing's contents changing is not a revision to a document", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [ "REFERENT" ], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "pics-pi-011", "source": { "id": "pics-pi-011", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/pics-pi-011" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-08/", "before_observed": "2026-08-07", "after_observed": "2026-08-08", "digest_before": "95bf4a66f2d44a2c2f6e16e4a3f5ebcf7e1199cdb972a8cf3051e02ed051c94b", "digest_after": "98ed07f87cddc9258d3cf715ee6653b8186f69423d1d67eaf4e75869a7ecce42", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 71 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 71 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-14", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-14/", "before_observed": "2026-08-13", "after_observed": "2026-08-14", "digest_before": "98ed07f87cddc9258d3cf715ee6653b8186f69423d1d67eaf4e75869a7ecce42", "digest_after": "15f94377c4fcaf40e77e3d0da24fce73b195aaa9da3fda0f362b83a7c7dbb30f", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 43 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 43 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-19", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-19/", "before_observed": "2026-08-18", "after_observed": "2026-08-19", "digest_before": "15f94377c4fcaf40e77e3d0da24fce73b195aaa9da3fda0f362b83a7c7dbb30f", "digest_after": "9269c75204ff905cfc9871d03a11c60990eff52d5875a86aa431ea184a136ac3", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 33 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 33 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-19", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-21", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-21/", "before_observed": "2026-08-20", "after_observed": "2026-08-21", "digest_before": "9269c75204ff905cfc9871d03a11c60990eff52d5875a86aa431ea184a136ac3", "digest_after": "4d93ac00b602eb73b4f50d6bc730afd4b0c6a1c5f38ab9a00ed6c497ff3c16b7", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 31 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 31 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-21", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-28", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-28/", "before_observed": "2026-08-27", "after_observed": "2026-08-28", "digest_before": "4d93ac00b602eb73b4f50d6bc730afd4b0c6a1c5f38ab9a00ed6c497ff3c16b7", "digest_after": "825750c5633d8d0299adadff01680f6f94689833bb570c934220d92fd4fef999", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-29", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-29/", "before_observed": "2026-08-28", "after_observed": "2026-08-29", "digest_before": "825750c5633d8d0299adadff01680f6f94689833bb570c934220d92fd4fef999", "digest_after": "39db0dd17f535777d791e1b3464473c40204c601dcebee5a72fd73987e3bbb68", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-31", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-08-31/", "before_observed": "2026-08-30", "after_observed": "2026-08-31", "digest_before": "39db0dd17f535777d791e1b3464473c40204c601dcebee5a72fd73987e3bbb68", "digest_after": "244eba4196bb8ace3eac640c46ffad760e2221de4b534126a7e581ea53d3f979", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-31", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-02", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-02/", "before_observed": "2026-09-01", "after_observed": "2026-09-02", "digest_before": "244eba4196bb8ace3eac640c46ffad760e2221de4b534126a7e581ea53d3f979", "digest_after": "605180a389c79c559d0f1d04db24d579607d00e7727893b28010b969673089ef", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "13 of 13 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-03", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "605180a389c79c559d0f1d04db24d579607d00e7727893b28010b969673089ef", "digest_after": "ed1c9acbb776eda4080e8b6f28b71e4c348cc573a604e598e9f84b408c871db0", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-09", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-26", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-11-2026-09-26/", "before_observed": "2026-09-25", "after_observed": "2026-09-26", "digest_before": "ed1c9acbb776eda4080e8b6f28b71e4c348cc573a604e598e9f84b408c871db0", "digest_after": "bbbd805d0905b3d3bb337aec7f6e0beaac465100b0fdcd1a1083168b7685fa93", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "31 of 31 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-27", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-11", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-11" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-26", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-08/", "before_observed": "2026-08-07", "after_observed": "2026-08-08", "digest_before": "393b48f902b837662950a1aec5bca642ec0dc2b1487d5dec104ccd6373b451fa", "digest_after": "5997ebbb66615f64b6eeee4e643bbae371cfa262fa2aae4b19645508b3189561", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 70 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 70 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-14", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-14/", "before_observed": "2026-08-13", "after_observed": "2026-08-14", "digest_before": "5997ebbb66615f64b6eeee4e643bbae371cfa262fa2aae4b19645508b3189561", "digest_after": "9d7b6d9aa4e134c40e14f458fc10130b2c105e71fd482694c63a306dc77f1d43", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 8 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 8 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-19", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-19/", "before_observed": "2026-08-18", "after_observed": "2026-08-19", "digest_before": "9d7b6d9aa4e134c40e14f458fc10130b2c105e71fd482694c63a306dc77f1d43", "digest_after": "18e04a0c925a01486357077898c82ba38eb236f8f4423a2071952465e827a0d8", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 33 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 33 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-19", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-21", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-21/", "before_observed": "2026-08-20", "after_observed": "2026-08-21", "digest_before": "18e04a0c925a01486357077898c82ba38eb236f8f4423a2071952465e827a0d8", "digest_after": "1e7f136841292df1484cbe2668c3f941f7005a63539be671db5cdb831bd57a59", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 31 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 31 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-21", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-28", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-28/", "before_observed": "2026-08-27", "after_observed": "2026-08-28", "digest_before": "1e7f136841292df1484cbe2668c3f941f7005a63539be671db5cdb831bd57a59", "digest_after": "f24b92ecdf425f86f463835a80a86142c45308ee43cdba5c7d6f64d4845bf23d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-29", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-29/", "before_observed": "2026-08-28", "after_observed": "2026-08-29", "digest_before": "f24b92ecdf425f86f463835a80a86142c45308ee43cdba5c7d6f64d4845bf23d", "digest_after": "b670ac9656b7eed06935ddab3e5382672dccf4d4f2f00bfa9c04815bd83c606d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-31", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-08-31/", "before_observed": "2026-08-30", "after_observed": "2026-08-31", "digest_before": "b670ac9656b7eed06935ddab3e5382672dccf4d4f2f00bfa9c04815bd83c606d", "digest_after": "bc527e48bcd825107e370b161505f7b4b261a1fdfe8cd71be2cedd70b1572971", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-31", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-02", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-02/", "before_observed": "2026-09-01", "after_observed": "2026-09-02", "digest_before": "bc527e48bcd825107e370b161505f7b4b261a1fdfe8cd71be2cedd70b1572971", "digest_after": "4edb9480421c24ce478d141081e716451837cc2dcdb0771da63b85912af7e0eb", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "13 of 13 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-03", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "4edb9480421c24ce478d141081e716451837cc2dcdb0771da63b85912af7e0eb", "digest_after": "cd3e1c0c936b59ded15e4c38e27a38b03e2e1d8b6a00fd2c82629696dd6a103c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-09", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-26", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-211-2026-09-26/", "before_observed": "2026-09-25", "after_observed": "2026-09-26", "digest_before": "cd3e1c0c936b59ded15e4c38e27a38b03e2e1d8b6a00fd2c82629696dd6a103c", "digest_after": "75605421c92f469578f34e38554e0e5ae754e93b92d5def51a9905f45e1b7440", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "31 of 31 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-27", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-211", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-211" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-26", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-08/", "before_observed": "2026-08-07", "after_observed": "2026-08-08", "digest_before": "8b8ac787c6877a1973785db6e13b8e6643271ebb4ee9403d7e9db717711c7124", "digest_after": "fa65ecef3a810b87382788c6b70bdfad819f167bc9bcf758ca15281140e88d63", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 70 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 27 of 70 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-14", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-14/", "before_observed": "2026-08-13", "after_observed": "2026-08-14", "digest_before": "fa65ecef3a810b87382788c6b70bdfad819f167bc9bcf758ca15281140e88d63", "digest_after": "8ee8e1aad0a5196cfd8be9c3ea24d141240dbba3839be4290a3ab39607ca43a7", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 9 of 42 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-14", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-19", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-19/", "before_observed": "2026-08-18", "after_observed": "2026-08-19", "digest_before": "8ee8e1aad0a5196cfd8be9c3ea24d141240dbba3839be4290a3ab39607ca43a7", "digest_after": "f3605b69e136dcbd96942e1b86545d684c1142b0bfee668ba2114db3fb5df41c", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 32 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 32 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-19", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-21", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-21/", "before_observed": "2026-08-20", "after_observed": "2026-08-21", "digest_before": "f3605b69e136dcbd96942e1b86545d684c1142b0bfee668ba2114db3fb5df41c", "digest_after": "baa155d883e3c444c5b7f46502cad12d29aa4a65ee0d9633c292e5f54ef6eb52", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 8 of 30 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 8 of 30 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-21", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-28", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-28/", "before_observed": "2026-08-27", "after_observed": "2026-08-28", "digest_before": "baa155d883e3c444c5b7f46502cad12d29aa4a65ee0d9633c292e5f54ef6eb52", "digest_after": "ac6e97a3c75da60bbe14670cc9b3b4cc27356d812734f74467368d56a02ff579", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 21 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-28", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-29", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-29/", "before_observed": "2026-08-28", "after_observed": "2026-08-29", "digest_before": "ac6e97a3c75da60bbe14670cc9b3b4cc27356d812734f74467368d56a02ff579", "digest_after": "bb66b9cbb2c4048ee8e7201c3dbc9998689b1b2cc89588d337d623462dec1d7d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 2 of 19 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-29", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-31", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-08-31/", "before_observed": "2026-08-30", "after_observed": "2026-08-31", "digest_before": "bb66b9cbb2c4048ee8e7201c3dbc9998689b1b2cc89588d337d623462dec1d7d", "digest_after": "0e1bbcb2d14d663f658ef6b96d6d9e96dcca0b1578d109b833eef81beea80f9b", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "unstable", "detail": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the new digest holds on only 1 of 16 later observation(s) taken under the same extractor: the text is unstable, not changed (59 further reading(s) excluded: the extractor moved)", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": true, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-08-31", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-02", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-02/", "before_observed": "2026-09-01", "after_observed": "2026-09-02", "digest_before": "0e1bbcb2d14d663f658ef6b96d6d9e96dcca0b1578d109b833eef81beea80f9b", "digest_after": "0eb9eade18684365c4e5887827e80f4e5d33640735d8c3f6aaf75bc73beb506d", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "furniture-only", "cause": null, "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "furniture-only", "detail": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "the differing spans are not document body: NOT-CHANGED", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": "NOT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "13 of 13 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-03", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-02", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-08", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-08/", "before_observed": "2026-09-07", "after_observed": "2026-09-08", "digest_before": "0eb9eade18684365c4e5887827e80f4e5d33640735d8c3f6aaf75bc73beb506d", "digest_after": "94a77d5625e80437cff61773776997c68ef0e942838a5c000c812e9dfc315ce1", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "BLOCKED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": null, "cause": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "BODY", "state": "BLOCKED", "class": "extractor-moved-across-the-pair", "detail": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "extractor stability is MOVED: 2 extractor-path commit(s) fall between 2026-09-07 and 2026-09-08", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "NORMALISED-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "MOVED", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "5 of 5 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-09", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [ { "limb": "BODY", "field": "class_lacks", "value": "the raw body was not retained on either side; no extractor version is stamped on the record", "why": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" } ], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-08", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-26", "instrument_id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/us-21-cfr-part-820-2026-09-26/", "before_observed": "2026-09-25", "after_observed": "2026-09-26", "digest_before": "94a77d5625e80437cff61773776997c68ef0e942838a5c000c812e9dfc315ce1", "digest_after": "ca64082d7f232821febd374e5e6c9805ec039ac27389635d71d1d8580d9538fd", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "31 of 31 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-09-27", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "source": { "id": "us-21-cfr-part-820", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/us-21-cfr-part-820" }, "observed_at": "2026-09-26", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "who-ai-health-2026-10-09", "instrument_id": "who-ai-health", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/who-ai-health-2026-10-09/", "before_observed": "2026-10-08", "after_observed": "2026-10-09", "digest_before": "65c06d0ec2abce03f7a09f5833d0aee77222e069367c6c7cedb867fa5f1253fc", "digest_after": "d26e30928de27fa4a5e4d60ce02c3f1d6c3a63a993cba994247f8c7b5711175a", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "basis": null, "rule_version": null, "class": "reverted", "cause": null, "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "needs": null, "findings": [ { "limb": "PERSIST", "state": "NOT-CHANGED", "class": "reverted", "detail": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted" } ], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "FAIL", "why": "none of the 17 later observation(s) carries the new digest: the text reverted", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": true, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": null, "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "who-ai-health", "source": { "id": "who-ai-health", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/who-ai-health" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-09", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" }, { "candidate_id": "who-ai-health-2026-10-10", "instrument_id": "who-ai-health", "url": "https://gxplex.com/candidates/who-ai-health-2026-10-10/", "before_observed": "2026-10-09", "after_observed": "2026-10-10", "digest_before": "d26e30928de27fa4a5e4d60ce02c3f1d6c3a63a993cba994247f8c7b5711175a", "digest_after": "65c06d0ec2abce03f7a09f5833d0aee77222e069367c6c7cedb867fa5f1253fc", "verdict": { "placed": true, "state": "CONFIRMED-DERIVED", "basis": "DERIVED", "rule_version": "sha256:b6e855c8950bb7f5", "class": null, "cause": null, "detail": null, "needs": null, "findings": [], "model_read": null, "model_read_receipt": null, "reproducible": null, "witness_address": null, "statements": null, "window": null, "triple": null, "read_from": "state/candidate-states.json" }, "limbs_read": true, "limbs": [ { "limb": "BYTES", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the retained normalised text differs, both observations answered HTTP 200 with no truncation marker, and both carry a digest", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "BODY", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "differing spans sit in the document body, and no extractor-path commit falls between the two observation days", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": "RAW-PROVEN", "class_lacks": "", "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": "STABLE", "span_verdict": "TEXT-CHANGED" } }, { "limb": "PERSIST", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "16 of 16 later observation(s) carry the new digest, the first on 2026-10-11", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } }, { "limb": "REFERENT", "verdict": "PASS", "why": "the row hashes the address it declares; 0 dated entries in its reading, below the 12 that would make it a list", "flags": { "waiting": null, "blocked": null, "unstable": null, "alternating": null, "below_floor": null, "readings_needed": null, "blocking_commits": null, "evidence_class": null, "class_lacks": null, "unanchored": null, "incomplete": null, "equal_digests": null, "missing_side": null, "not_the_artifact": null, "unlike_referents": null, "reverted": null, "unaudited": null, "referent_mismatch": null, "referent_verdict": null, "extractor_verdict": null, "span_verdict": null } } ], "limbs_not_in_projection": [], "missing_evidence": [], "witness": { "witness": false, "witness_address": null, "offered_as_witness_change": false, "confirmation_subject": "instrument", "read_from": "state/triple-projection.json" }, "text_retained": true, "licence_class": "open", "quote_allowed": true, "snapshot_available": true, "rights_of": "who-ai-health", "source": { "id": "who-ai-health", "state": "tracked", "resolves_to": "https://gxplex.com/r/who-ai-health" }, "observed_at": "2026-10-10", "observed_at_state": "recorded", "observed_at_read_from": "after_observed", "distance": null, "distance_label": null, "distance_state": "not-a-signal" } ] }